|2004 Royalty: (back) Amber Barff, Tiffany Olsen, Heidi VanWagoner, (front) Tandi Olsen, and Whitney Murdock.|
The Miss Elmo Pageant was held on June 26 at Cleveland Town Hall. Contestants were Jayla Weston and Tandi Olsen for the Miss Tiny Tot category; Brooklyn Fish and Whitney Murdock for Little Miss Elmo; Amber Barff and Kylee Jennings for Princess; Tiffany Olsen, Shylo Pearson and Stacy Villa for Jr. Miss Elmo; and Heidi VanWagoner for Miss Elmo. Reigning Queens were Erin Anselmo, Miss Elmo; Amy Lofley, Jr. Miss Elmo; Katelin Mortensen, Princess; Jenna Mortensen, Little Miss; and Nikki Borba, Tiny Tot.
Winners were: Tandi Olsen, Tiny Tot; Whitney Murdock, Little Miss Elmo; Amber Barff, Princess; Tiffany Olsen, Jr. Miss Elmo; and Heidi VanWagoner, Miss Elmo.
Judges were Kimber Ellison, Careshmeh Mele and Kaylee VanWagoner.